Where to start? Almost eight years in I have finally cracked open some books on parenting. It hasn't been the most pleasant of reading experiences. Books for parents feel forced, oversimplified, and I keep finding myself thinking, "This guy pretends he knows what he is talking about, but he actually beats his kids when nobody's looking."
Both of the books I have skimmed, leafed through dealt with what is termed as active listening, reflecting back what is told to you while coaxing the child to find his or her own solution to a problem. This is the core of Thomas Gordon's Parent Effectiveness Training and Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish's Siblings Without Rivalry.
At first glance, it seems a little ridiculous. Marta says, "Anna took my doll." And you are supposed to say, "Anna took your doll, huh?" And then Marta says, "Yes, she did." And then you say, "You must be pretty frustrated that she took your doll." And Marta answers, "Yes, I am." And that's about as far as I have gotten with this active listening stuff. I have noticed that it reduces tensions in certain situations. By getting Marta to talk about her feelings, she does calm down a little. But I still have no solution to the main issue, that Anna took her doll.
Another gem is to pay attention to the child being hit in a dispute. If Marta hits Anna, I pay attention to Anna. "Did Marta hit you?" And vice versa. I can already see that the "hitter" dislikes the attention that the "hittee" gets in the situation. Still not sure where this is going.
There's a lot of discord around here. Marta and Anna fight like crazy. They just fight to fight. Other times they play nice. Maria Leena has some idea of what is going on, but she's mostly concerned with being fed and having her diaper changed and sleeping.
With Maria I have had my first experience with what some call "name remorse." Except it is not that I am not happy with her name or could think of a better one, it's just that I find it hard to say it sometimes. I call her "Anna" by accident. I wonder, should we have given her another one? Well, too late now. I think the problem is that Maria Leena is rather pretty and ladylike, and not always befitting of a small round child that lets out enormous farts and whose hair sticks up in the middle like some kind of Cirque du Soleil clown.
So I was playing around with nicknames and came up with Mämmu, which is a child's word here that means something like "yummy." Mämmu seems to do the trick, and I no longer call Maria "Anna" by accident. I don't call her this all the time, only sometimes, but I like it.
Oh, I am tired now. It is past 1 am. Being a father is tiring because all the little ones want you to meet their needs. Get me this, fix this, pay attention to this ... I'm in demand. That's always good.
I am excited about Christmas this year. We're not doing the flight to New York and our home is very cozy (last year we were in a different apartment that was less cozy). I want to get a nice tree and decorate it. The girls have already been making gingerbread cookies almost every night. I feel like I haven't done Christmas "right" the few times that we have been able to do it on our own. But, I am getting older, maturing, and I know I can get it right this time.
We went to see the Nutcracker yesterday and we loved it. Other than a few sporadic arguments between Marta and Anna all went well. They paid attention to the whole thing. I fell asleep during the first part but was awake for the second (which, in my opinion, was the best part). I kept thinking of how Tchaikovsky wrote all of that music, what a gifted person he was, how he was from Russia, how that world, the tsarist era, is so completely lost. It's a shame.
9 comments:
Oh Justin this was such a nice post.
Yes I was trained with PET... actually doid a workshop on it.
Ha! You benefited... . : )
Pay attention to the victim, it actually does work somewhat..
The doll, Anna wants a doll with "real hair"... she will be getting one hopefully she, her doll is on her way via the US Post Office.
Hopefully it will be under the tree on Christmas Morning.
I am sad that your not going to be here for Christmas ... but I am happy that you will have a nice time in your cozy little home with a big tree and lots of presents.
Marta said you have never had a real Christmas there "ever" so it's nice that you are stepping it up.
Re name remorse... remember she wanted to be called Lucy .. she said so. : )
I also have taken the PET course, lasted many months (6 months?), when we lived in Tartu. Remind me, I will look for the "workbook" in the office.
Marta is saying things that people expect, maybe? We have had at least two Christmas in Estonia and yesterday we were just talking about these. She remembers Christmas in America and in Estonia, they are partly different but the Christmas spirit is the same.
I got thinking about the case "Anna took my doll". You see the "took the doll" as the main issue, but maybe it's really not. I have used this PET (we were on the course with Epp) a lot, too, and it seems to me, that the real issue is oftne the fact that the kid was hurt. The fact that Anna took her doll hurt Marta. She wants to be understood that she got hurt and she is feeling bad. Of course, she wants her doll back, but in fact, if you really dig into it, it is not the main issue! What I do (works in most cases, not all) is that I really take time to reflect back the child's feelings and often she'd soon forget about the doll. And the other one does not want it either because now she'd get jealous of all the attention that the first one gets. huh, can you still follow? :) And then I'd say, hey, let's think how can we all solve the problem. It takes some practicing but soon they become really skillful problem-solvers.
It's so cool that a father like you would honestly write about your own challenges.
Epp... Marta said this in the summer and I am well aware that at times she .. just makes things up...but I was there 3 days after Christmas and you had a tiny tree from the grocery store that was on the table and it had no decorations on it.
I am not saying that you need to have a huge tree with hundreds of old ornaments and candles and wreaths in all of your windows ... but I can see why she felt it was a let down and I am happy Justin is as he has said, mature now, and plans for it to be a nice Christmas for the girls.
Helen...
Marta and Anna are so just different from one another.
Marta feels right or wrong that Anna "gets away with everything". and Anna simply delights in getting Marta in as much trouble as she possibly can.
Anna wants what Marta has or will take it just to watch all the drama that unfolds.
Marta yells at her, then Mom or Dad get involved (or Mimi)... and when Marta finally gets told to share or that she isn't being nice to her little sister the result is that Anna finally gets the attention that she so craved and just cannot seem to get any other way.
Poor little Anna was behaving like the middle child long before she was the middle child.
Parenting is just messy...
Very interesting angle, from the book "Siblings With0ut Rivalry": how we should not lock our kids into the stereotypes, labelling "she is always like this and he is always like that". I have noticed that we do it sometimes... we should not. I have felt myself how unpleasant it is when you are "locked into a role". And it creates bad blood between siblings. Yes, parenting is messy business :)
Christine, that Xmas tree was small but it was alive and still is :). And it had the decorations on.
We took the tree from our Karksi estate last year, the young forest is too thick there.
Its not only tree, its the spirit, and I know we have the spirit, and I see that my girls believe in it as well.
AND IT IS SNOWING! Finally.
Epp,
I am not saying that this is the only reason for their sibling issues.
The main reason for them is that they are "siblings", and just kids fight over many things or anything. This was just one little vignette of behavior that I have observed.
You are there all the time I am sure there are many triggers.
I might just be a bit more objective only because I am not with them all the time and so I have a different prospective... and I have been in the parent business for 40 years... made my own share of mistakes and watched as my friends and family made theirs.
... like we agreeded parenting is messy.
My cousin Jeanette, mother of 6 once said "our 1st child survives in spite of all of the mistakes that we make."
Will you once again send out the footman to help to procure your tree from your "Karksi Estate" ?
Since we are not elitists we will
simply be going to Anne Marie's Organic farmstand to buy our tree.
: )
Post a Comment